Archive - Twitter RSS Feed

3 Reasons for NOT engaging, Why Bother with Twitter

Top 7 Facebook & Twitter Strategies, EZ Breezy Worpdress Social Plugins

MTV, The Twitopularity Rise & The 2012 Elections [VIDEO]

Not a TV buff by any stretch of the imagination to begin with, I usually shun the MTV awards type events but the social experiment underlined by the Twitter firehose that MTV put up was well worth watching as it may much farther reaching implications than promoting simple music videos. MTV’s spokesman Kurk Patat said it’s all:

“The conversation is already taking place, we want to be where that conversation is taking place.”

The best way to describe the MTV Tweetracker is visually, check out the video below. The site can basically be displayed in either stripped or cloud view.

Once you open the site, simple instructions appear: the visual graph contains pictures of the most popular topics/people at that moment, as a topic or person becomes more popular the image grows, with the most popular topic keeping steady in the center of the graph, if you click on an image you can access all the related tweets. The stripped provides a view a bit more structured, with ranking list of subject/people and tweets shooting out firehose style. You even get a scrubber at the bottom to go back in time; very helpful as the whole thing is actually pretty overwhelming… as a firehose would feel like if it was shooting you right in the face.

The interesting thing about this stunt is that the immediate question that popped in my mind was, how might this look in the context of elections where we wouldn’t be talking about a quick 2-hour stream but a month long firehose. Many people could be putting a similar Tweetracker together since Twitter data is open.

But who would it be and which attributes would make it the winner against its competitors? Political parties will probably jump at the opportunity; by 2012 Twitter will only have ingrained itself further in society. Would unfiltered Twitter data, and an ability to handle counter trends gracefully, be the key to the winning firehose platform?

Take the MTV Tweetracker for a spin

Twitter Accused of Censorship, Does it Need Circuit Breakers?

In the wake of Israel raiding ships carrying aid en route for Gaza, sparking furor on Twitter, something strange happened on the micro-blogging site that stirred a lot of reactions. The hashtag, a way to categorize information on Twitter, pertaining to the raid was #flotilla. It somehow disappeared from Twitter trends for a while before reappearing.

Whether it was a technical snafu or actual censorship, this issue raises flags about Twitter for many as well as about the very essence of the openness of social media.

Had you tried yesterday the standard URL to search for the latest on the subject – http://search.twitter.com/search?q=%23flotilla – you would

have briefly gotten a result saying “Twitter error”. Was it an honest mistake, a technically algorithmic mishap or an act of censorship?

Many were quick to defend Twitter as censorship not being in “present in its DNA”. Sean Garrett (@SG), communication head for Twitter, tweeted:

Sean Garrett Tweet re Flotilla

Just as many did ask the question: Was Twitter censoring the #flotilla related tweets because those were, in their majority, critical of Israel?

Mike Butcher (@mikebutcher) from TechCrunch Europe outlined in great details the technicalities of the hashtag disappearance to conclude it related to Twitter’s anti-spam algorithm rules

#Flotilla Google trends

being tripped by the rapid rise of the #flotilla hashtag. Also explaining why, at the same time, #Israil (Turk for Israel) was trending instead of its English version. This, all the while “twitter flotilla” was strongly trending on Google.

John Dean Techcrunch EU Comment Flotilla

But several comments, without being political, did not seem to buy the explanation. As “John Dean” called the conclusion flawed.

Others, such as “Imran”, outright mocked the explanation. Comparing to the otherwise long-trending topic of  the Iranian elections topic, even driving users to add a greenish taint to  their avatars in support of the protestors.--

Imran-Comment-Techcrunch-Flotilla-twitter-trend.png-

-

-

-

-

Despite Mike Butcher’s plea to keep politics out the TechCrunch post, comments inevitably veered towards heated exchanges on conspiracy theories.

Fayez Techcrunch Comment location based flotilla

Charles Arthur (@CharlesArthur), technology editor at The Guardian, seconded the snafu as technical by pointing to an independent map (Trendsmap) showing people quickly shifting hashtag to #freedomflotilla after the disappearance of the shorter version and which trended rapidly thus, according to the author, disproving the censorship theory.

Tom Foremski (@TomForemski) from the Silicon Valley Watcher, on the other hand brought up the idea of whether Twitter, and social media in general, was in need of the same “circuit breakers” in place for the stock market; for instance when

“…news dissemination is far faster, far more viral, and the subject might be something which could trigger in riots, violence, or other possible distress, to a society or region?”

Regardless of political orientation and the reasons behind the temporary vanishing of the #flotilla hashtag, this issue raised flags about Twitter for many as well as about the very essence of the openness of social media.

If social media is about openness and trust, wouldn’t “social circuit breakers” defeat the whole purpose of social and new media and its promise? Does this mean that people will in the future relinquish common sense and judgment to social networks? And even then, how long could the people be misguided by a “false” trend? Who would decide to trip the breaker? Humans or machines? How would that affect the very willingness to participate in social media? The question will eventually hinge on, how much information actually gets to people and how much of it might be filtered out.

What do you think? Did Twitter censor or was it simply a technical mishap? How about having circuit breakers?

Page 2 of 2«12